Who is the Greatest Rookie in Baseball History?

Vote Now!

Current Leaders

  1. Jackie Robinson
  2. Mike Trout
  3. Shohei Ohtani
  4. Aaron Judge
  5. Albert Pujols
  6. Josh Gibson
  7. Mark Fidrych
  8. Ichiro Suzuki
  9. Paul Skenes
  10. Ken Griffey Jr.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Goat Vote determine the all-time baseball ranking?

We tally every top-ten vote our members have cast, awarding points based on rank (first is worth the most, tenth is worth the least).

Which players are eligible?

Everyone who ever played is eligible, regardless of era, league, nationality, or gender. You can add anyone who's missing.

What are the criteria?

That's up to you. Numbers, highlights, accolades, what a team would look like without them: every member weighs them differently, and the standings are the sum of all those calls.

Can I vote more than once?

Absolutely! A free account gets you one ranked ballot per day.

More Baseball Votes

More GOAT Votes

Goat Vote logo