The Goat Vote Blog
Blog
Hot takes, cold numbers, and the eternal debate over who deserves MVP and GOAT status in baseball, basketball, football, hockey, and soccer.
Is Paul Skenes or Tarik Skubal the Best Pitcher?
Starting pitchers have become devalued in recent years, as injuries have ravaged their ranks and managers have increasingly come to rely on specialists coming out of the bullpen. Clayton Kershaw just wrapped up his sparkling farewell season, and the glory days of his fellow future Hall of Famers Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander are well behind them. However, a bright new generation of talents has emerged over the last few years, led by the incomparable Tarik Skubal and Paul Skenes. Who's the best, though?
Read article →-
Is Aaron Judge or Cal Raleigh the 2025 AL MVP?
Comparing these two remarkable players is in many ways an exercise in futility. Judge is favored by most advanced metrics, all of which have clearly established for years that he and Ohtani are head and shoulders above their peers in offensive value. However, Raleigh's value is boosted greatly by his defense, which cannot be accurately captured statistically due to the inherently nebulous nature of calling games and framing pitches.
Read article → -
Is Shai Gilgeous-Alexander or Nikola Jokić the Real MVP?
The 2025 NBA MVP race was one for the history books, with two international superstars — Canada's Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Serbia's Nikola Jokić — delivering performances that redefined excellence. The league announced earlier today that the voters have selected SGA as the winner, sparking a firestorm of discussion about which player had the more compelling case. Let's attempt to answer the million dollar question: Who really deserved to take home the Michael Jordan Trophy?
Read article → -
Is Tom Brady Really the Greatest of All Time?
Tom Brady is an iconic figure in NFL history, a quarterback whose sustained success vastly exceeded what was previously thought possible. With seven Super Bowl rings, five Super Bowl MVPs, and a career spanning more than two decades, he's built a resume that seems untouchable. His ability to orchestrate clutch drives, outsmart defenses, and elevate teams has made him a legend. But as Patrick Mahomes continues to dazzle and historical giants like Joe Montana and Peyton Manning loom large, we must ask: Is Brady really the Greatest of All Time? Let's consider the evidence.
Read article → -
Is Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, or Lamar Jackson the Best QB?
With all due respect to reigning Super Bowl MVP Jalen Hurts, the 2025 NFL quarterback landscape is dominated by three electrifying talents: Kansas City's Patrick Mahomes, Buffalo's Josh Allen, and Baltimore's Lamar Jackson. Each brings a unique blend of creativity, mobility, and leadership, sparking debates about who reigns supreme. With unprecedented stats, iconic performances, and transformative impacts on their teams, the question isn't just who's the best now, but who's carving out the greatest legacy.
Read article → -
Is Michael Jordan Really the Greatest of All Time?
Michael Jordan is a singular figure in basketball, a player who redefined what greatness means in the sport. With a blend of athleticism, skill, and unrelenting competitiveness, he dominated the NBA like no one before or since. His six championships, five MVPs, and countless iconic moments have cemented his status as a sporting legend. But as LeBron James continues to rewrite the record book, we must ask ourselves: Does Jordan hold the title of Greatest of All Time? Let's examine the evidence.
Read article → -
Is Sidney Crosby or Alexander Ovechkin the Better Player?
When discussing the best careers in the history of the NHL, legendary names like Wayne Gretzky, Mario Lemieux, and Bobby Orr often dominate the conversation. But in the 21st century, two icons stand head and shoulders above the rest: Sidney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin. Sharing a rookie year (2005-06) has linked them forever like Magic Johnson and Larry Bird, and both have piled up awards, records, and unforgettable moments. So, who ranks higher on the list of greatest hockey players of all time — Crosby or Ovechkin? Let's compare and contrast.
Read article → -
Is the GOAT Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, or Pelé?
The debate over the greatest footballer of all time is as timeless as the sport itself, with three names consistently rising to the top in recent years: Argentina's Lionel Messi, Portugal's Cristiano Ronaldo, and Brazil's Pelé. Each has a compelling case, backed by jaw-dropping stats, iconic moments, and transformative impacts on the game. Let's break down their claims to the throne and explore why this question remains so fiercely contested.
Read article → -
Is Aaron Judge Already an All Time Yankee?
Aaron Judge is a towering figure in baseball, both literally and figuratively. At 6'7" and 282 pounds, he's a homerun-hitting colossus who's redefined power in the modern era. With numerous accolades and record-breaking campaigns to his name, Judge has cemented himself as one of the greatest ballplayers in recent memory. But does he already have a spot on the roster of All Time New York Yankees, rubbing shoulders with legends like Babe Ruth, Joe DiMaggio, and Mickey Mantle? That's a tough question, given the crowded outfield. Let's dive in.
Read article → -
Is Shohei Ohtani Already in the GOAT Conversation?
Shohei Ohtani is a unicorn in a sport where we thought we'd seen it all. Simultaneously a pitcher who throws 100 mph and a slugger who launches 450-foot homers, he's rewriting what's possible in baseball. No one's had his cultural impact since Babe Ruth, and even Ruth didn't pitch and hit at this level simultaneously. Ohtani is also much more athletic and likely a bigger star globally than even the Babe was in his heyday. So, here's the question buzzing in sports bars and social media alike: Does Ohtani already belong in the Greatest of All Time discussion? Let's break it down.
Read article →